Блог

Why do people in Shorts just watch other people’s videos?

Юрий Мельников

A funny clip is playing, and someone in the corner is smiling or clutching their head. Sometimes they manage to look surprised before anything has even happened on screen.

I’ve been seeing a lot of Shorts like this lately. Some viral clip is playing, and there’s a person in the corner watching it too. Sometimes they smile, sometimes they clutch their head. And sometimes nothing particularly interesting has even happened on screen yet, but they’re already delighted.

And I look at them and think: why are you here?

I remember when Ray William Johnson made his show Equals Three. On the Russian-speaking internet, there was This Is Хорошо with Stas Davydov. They showed other people’s videos too. But the host could point out some detail you had missed, make a joke about it, or even build a whole sketch around it. Even if you had already seen the clip, it was still interesting to see what they would do with it.

Johnson left the show, and for a while it continued with other hosts. This Is Хорошо gradually moved into news commentary, and later the team announced that the channel was shutting down.

And now I look at the person in the corner of the screen and think: if you took them away, what would I lose? Sometimes, I think I would simply get to see what was happening in that corner.

Then I realized what it reminded me of: laugh tracks in sitcoms. I always felt as if they were telling me where I was supposed to laugh. And, by the way, I’m seeing that laugh track in Shorts again too. Only nastier.

But it did have one advantage. At least it didn’t take up space in the frame.